Wednesday, 8 July 1998
Exuberance is Beauty
Tuesday, 30 June 1998
Amoghasiddhi – Nothing To Fear
This talk was given at the London Buddhist Centre, June 1998
Amoghasiddhi is perhaps the most mysterious of the Archetypal Buddhas. Almost everything about Amoghasiddhi demonstrates a seeming contradiction or paradox. His symbolism includes lots of opposites, opposing forces, and these opposites, these opposing forces, are united in Amoghasiddhi.
Amoghasiddhi is associated with midnight. He is visualised in a deep blue sky, a velvety blue in colour, the colour of the night sky in the Tropics. His imagery includes a couple of strange features. First of all his lotus throne is supported by two mythical figures, known as Shang-Shang birds which are half human half bird. In their hands they hold cymbals which they clash together. Amoghasiddhi is green in colour and his left hand rests in his lap holding a double vajra, a very potent symbol , which I will return to. His right hand is held up, palm outwards in the Abhaya mudra: the gesture of fearlessness. In this talk I'm going to focus mainly on two aspects of Amoghasiddhi, the aspect associated with the Abhaya mudra, the gesture of fearlessness and the aspect associated with the double vajra.
Bhante Sangharakshita has said that all fear is at bottom a fear of death. We could see this in two ways: as relating to physical death and also as relating to spiritual death, death of the ego. There is of course a connection between the two, because the fact of our physical decay and death reminds us that we are not totally in control of our lives and it is loss of control that we often fear when we need to let go into a bigger spiritual Reality. We experience ourselves as being substantial beings, in a particular time and place, occupying a certain amount of space, possessing certain things which are ours and with intelligence, feelings, appetites, all of which we satisfy as best we can. We are here and we are alive and we have a name and personality and identity. And yet, death awaits us. There are many ways to respond to this dilemma. We may turn away and reassure ourselves that we are here and alive or we may run and hide or stand and stare in a state of confusion. Whether we reassure ourselves or hide or become bewildered, our response in its nakedness is one of fear, horror even, perhaps even indignation or rage. What have I done to deserve this? Or What has my friend or parent done to deserve this? It's not fair. Anger is frustrated craving and what we crave is life. We want to hang on to life. We don't want to grow old or to die, or to suffer in any way. We don't want to see our friends sickening or dying or suffering. We want to be alive and to be happy.
We reassure ourselves that we are alive and we pursue happiness through our relationships with other people and via our possessions, whether material or intellectual. We hide from death and decay by distancing ourselves with television, cinema, shopping, fashion, falling in love, making plans and so on. Or in extreme cases by falling into addiction. A state of bewilderment or confusion is a step further on than self-reassurance or running away because at least here we are facing the facts: we are decaying, we will die, it horrifies us and we are thoroughly confused by it. Bryan Magee writes: “I used to look at people going about their normal lives with everyday cheerfulness and think: “How can they? And how can they suppose that any of what they are doing matters? They're like passengers on the Titanic, except that these people know already that they're headed for total and irremediable shipwreck. In a short time every one of them will be dead, either a heap of grey ash in an urn or a corpse rotting underground with worms wriggling in and out of its eye sockets. And that situation will be every bit as real then as their situation now is now; and it will last for very much longer. Why aren't they overwhelmed with horror at it? Why don't they seem even to mind?”. In my London club – which unlike most of the others was something like a family – I would look at middle-aged and elderly members and think: “How can they sit there enjoying their lunch, telling jokes, laughing, their eyes sparkling with pleasure? In a short time now they will be dead, all of the, and what's more they know it now. They're almost face to face with total oblivion. Don't they care?”. I was baffled by the fact that almost all human beings knew what was in store for them yet lived as if it were not so – or as if it were something that they were perfectly happy about. Above all, I was baffled by the fact that the middle aged, who were so close to death, tended to be even more cheerful than the young. In some of my moods they seemed to me like a lot of lunatics chuckling dementedly while the asylum burnt down and turned them to ash.” (Confessions of a Philosopher, p.266)
This sort of state has potential for wisdom in it. However most of us, most of the time have not got that far. We are still trying to reassure ourselves that we will live forever and we think we just need to make a few adjustments here and there and life will be pretty perfect and we can sit back, put our feet up and relax. But life keeps knocking us back: our plans don't work out, someone close to us dies, we lose our job, our partner runs off with someone else, and the bank raises its interest rates. Or we are afraid of these things happening. We are afraid that we will be alone and impoverished. Many people have a sort of secret horror that they will grow old alone and poverty stricken, wandering the streets uncared for, and since it does happen to some people it's not a totally unrealistic horror.
In response to these fears we put a lot of time and energy into finding and holding onto a lover, a family or friends to ensure that we won't be alone and we put time and energy into getting a good job, accumulating some money and property, enough to ensure that we won't be in want, we won't be impoverished. We experience fear or at least it lurks somewhere in the cellars of our mind and we find various ways of coping, none of which actually work.
And so perhaps we turn to Buddhism. And Buddhism tells us we are afraid because we are egotistic and our egotism is a state of gross delusion. Does that help us to cope with our fears? No. But fortunately Buddhism is above all practical and so we are given practices which we are told that if we follow them assiduously we will see through the delusion and experience a great sense of liberation and happiness. In a sense we won't really be beyond our fear of death and all fears until we gain Insight into the nature of Reality. But to borrow a phrase from Yeats, Insight “comes dropping slow like the morning dew.” In other words, Insight into Reality and freedom from the fetters of our deluded egotism is not necessarily going to be a big bang experience. It is more likely to be an accumulation of little insights that slowly drop into our psyche and gradually transform us. We have to pursue two parallel approaches to our fears: one, we need to undertake practices which help us cope with our fears, and two, we need also to, as it were, face the facts of life and through study, reflection and meditation gradually clarify our existential vision and prepare the ground for an intuitive and imaginative turning about in the depths of our being. What we need to help us cope with our fear is something to trust in. We try to put our trust in lovers and money and computers but somehow it doesn't quite work.
What can we trust in? Well there are different levels of trust. There are some things you can put some trust in but not total trust and there are some things you can trust totally. According to Buddhism you can have complete trust in the Buddha, the Dharma and the Arya Sangha. The Buddha represents the Enlightened mind or Reality. You can trust Reality. The Dharma is also Reality, it is the way things are. As well as that, the Dharma is the methods or path by which we come to see Reality. The Arya Sangha is all those who have gained Insight into the nature of Reality. So we can have complete trust in the Buddha, the ideal of Enlightenment, the Dharma, the Path, and the Arya Sangha, those who have attained Insight into Reality. But perhaps we need something more immediate and tangible to trust in, something that can take the place of money and property and so on. The Tantric tradition has addressed itself to this question and come up with some answers which are partially helpful to us.
In the Vajrayana tradition you put your trust in the Guru. Outside of that tradition it is virtually impossible to replicate the system of guru as Buddha without falling into all sorts of of confusion or worse. What we, in the Triratna Buddhist Community, have is the Kalyana Mitra, Spiritual Friend; someone a bit more experienced on the path. We place our full trust in the Buddha and we place some degree of trust in our Kalyana Mitra. We trust them in matters pertaining to the spiritual path. But we retain our own judgment and autonomy. The Kalyana Mitra, spiritual friend is simply someone more experienced on the spiritual path than we are, someone we respond to with faith. We judge from their behaviour, their speech and from our intuition that they are indeed more spiritually experienced and capable of giving us some guidance, not necessarily advice on how to live our lives, but some guidance on the spiritual path, in the realm of ethics, meditation and so on.
In terms of the Dharma refuge we simply put our trust in the practices; the precepts, generosity, the Metta Bhavana, the Mindfulness of Breathing. These are tried and tested practices. And we can put our trust in the concepts of dependent arising (pratitya samutpada) and karma as reflections of the way things are.
As regards the Sangha, we put our trust in friendship with others who share our aspirations and try to relate on the basis of that shared aspiration. Obviously we can't rely on our friends totally, they have human weaknesses and failings, but we can rely on each other to the extent that we re genuinely practising ethics and meditation. Our Kalyana Mitras, spiritual friends can be relied on to some degree. The practice and concepts of the Dharma can be relied on and our friends in the Sangha can be relied on to some extent. These all help us to cope with our fears. They are something to be getting on with until such time as Insight comes dropping slowly to penetrate to the depths of our being. As we pursue this approach of finding more reliable ways to cope with our existential and resultant fears, we also need to pursue the path of Insight through study, reflection and meditation.
By studying the concepts and symbols of the Dharma over and over again we learn to make connections that we hadn't seen before, we penetrate deeper into the meaning and this paves the way for us to gain an intuitive glimpse of Reality. When we become quite familiar with concepts such as dependent arising, the five precepts or the five skandhas or the three laksanas, (marks of conditioned existence) we will be able to turn them over in our minds, especially when on retreat and this sort of reflection or contemplation will gradually yield rewards. Even a simple concept like the phrase we sometimes use in the Metta Bhavana “May I make progress” can be the basis for reflection, or “All things are impermanent”. These reflections take us to the limits of our ability to intellectualise and then when we have reached the top of that particular pole, to use an image from Zen, we are in a position to make a wild leap into the unknown. Before that, for many times, we will simply slither back down to earth, feeling more confused than ever. It is not for nothing that it is said that Padmasambhava, who took Buddhism to Tibet, said “Let these three expressions: I do not have, I do not know, I do not understand, be repeated over and over again. That is the heart of my advice”. (The Life and Liberation of Padmasambhava, Part II, Canto 93, p.635) He was warning that our intellect will be battered to bits against the Walls of Reality, until we let go of grasping at intellectual answers and float free into the blue sky of Wisdom. If we pursue these parallel paths of finding more stable and safer things in which to trust and studying, reflecting and meditation on the truths of the Dharma, then we will be dealing creatively with our fears. We will also be gradually learning the message of Amoghasiddhi's Abhaya Mudra, the gesture of fearlessness. The message of this mudra is not that we must be fearless, but rather that there is nothing to fear. There is nothing whatsoever to be afraid of. Everything we fear is a phantom of our own mind. It is because we hold on to a particular view of ourselves and of the world that we are afraid. When we wake up from the dream of our wrong views, our delusions, we will be fearless because there will be nothing to fear. As the Heart Sutra says, “The Bodhisattva holding to nothing whatever is freed of delusive hindrance and rid of the fear bred by it.”. It is what we are holding onto that causes us to fear. When we finally let go there is nothing to fear.
However in the meantime we need to have a practice of fearlessness. Taking risks is the essence of the practice of fearlessness and courage. There is no easy way to deal with fear, it has to be faced. We can face it gradually, taking small steps at a time, small risks. What we are usually risking is humiliation or failure, loss of face. One of my biggest fears was always the fear of having to speak in front of other people. When I first came along to the London Buddhist Centre at the age of twenty eight, I was very shy, painfully shy. I found it very difficult to speak in any group even a small group of six or seven people. When I was about to be ordained I doubted whether I was really up to it because I thought Order Members had to give talks, teach meditation etc., and I just couldn't really see myself being able to do that. But, as you can see, something has changed and even though being up in front of a crowd of people is not necessarily my favourite activity, it doesn't bother me any more. It has been a gradual process of just doing it and feeling the discomfort and nervousness and fear of humiliation and sweating palms and shaking legs and having to go to the toilet five times before speaking etc. But ,as I say, I've cracked it and I don't even get nervous now. I'm just telling you that, because it might be encouraging. You may have your own fear. Some people for instance have no problem with speaking in groups but are frightened of having to be alone. There are all sorts of things we fear.
Traditionally the yogis went into the cremation ground at night to face their fears, ghosts, wild animals and the dead. We each have our own equivalent of a cremation ground. The cremation ground is the crucial situation that we find difficult to face; a particular communication, speaking up, going abroad, not being able to speak the language, what others think. We often 'prepare a face to meet the faces that we meet'. The practice of fearlessness is a practice of gradually taking risks, facing our crucial situation, entering our cremation ground. According to the Tantra when you come out the other side of your fear what you meet is the Dakini, the Sky Dancer, a naked female figure ,brilliant red in colour, dancing through the sky with complete abandon. This is a symbol of the tremendous freedom and energy that arises from facing fears and taking risks. So that's what we can look forward to, when we face fears. We can look forward to a great sense of freedom and a release of energy. We begin to live our lives more and more fully.
Now I'd like to go on to look at the symbolism of the double vajra. A vajra is a symbolic thunderbolt used in Tantric rituals and depicted in thangkhas or images of various Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, most notably Vajrasattva, Akshobya, Vajrapani, Amoghasiddhi and Padmasambhava. Very simply described, a vajra consists of a central sphere with five spokes emerging from it on each side. There is a lotus emerging from the centre on each side as well and the heads of some mythical beasts called Makara, like crocodiles. Each of these elements: the central sphere, the two sets of five spokes, the lotuses and the mythical beasts, has its own symbolism and the whole vajra is a very rich symbol. I'm not going to go into that now. Today I am concerned with the double vajra and I want to concentrate on the symbolism of the two sets of five spokes and say more things about the double vajra.
One set of five spokes represents the Five Buddhas and the Five Wisdoms. The five Wisdoms are the Mirror-like Wisdom of Akshobya, the Wisdom of Equality associated with Ratnasambhava, the Discriminating Wisdom of Amitabha, the All-Performing Wisdom of Amoghasiddhi, and the Absolute or Dharmadhatu Wisdom of Vairocana. The second set of five spokes represents various things but I want to concentrate on the five poisons. These are infatuation or spiritual ignorance, aversion, conceit, craving and jealousy or envy.
The vajra contains all these elements, the poisons and the wisdoms. It embraces opposites, it is a union of opposites and the double vajra re-emphasises this union of opposites. When you achieve a union of opposites, transformation takes place which gives rise to great energy and the double vajra is a symbol of tremendous energy. It is the spiritual equivalent of nuclear power. The energy of the double vajra is unstoppable, invincible, it is the energy of Enlightenment, the energy that arises when the forces of the psyche are transformed into the Wisdom of Reality.
On one side of the vajra we have negative energies; greed, hatred, ignorance, pride and jealousy and on the other side we have the positive energies of Transcendental Wisdom. But there is only one vajra and it contains both. There is only one energy which can be channelled in different ways. Our psyche, our mind is a vajra, a double vajra even and contains contradictions, opposites, conflicts. We are in conflict with ourselves and as we pursue the spiritual path the conflict intensifies. There is the conflict, the tension between our spiritual aspirations and our craving for distraction. There is the conflict between our ideals and the mundane reality of our lives. There is the conflict between our desire for immediate pleasure and the need for discipline. There is the conflict between our need for guidance and our fear of authority, and so on. Our lives are full of conflict and contradictions. Internally we experience conflict and tension in terms of opposing tendencies and desires and externally we experience the conflict of encountering other minds and other selves beyond our control or understanding.
This conflict and contradiction can seem a chaos and can be very painful as we try desperately to impose order on the unruly forces of our own mind and try to control the world around us. The mistake we make often, is that we try to banish or defeat or obliterate one side of the conflict in our minds. This just causes even greater problems. We cannot become good by banishing the bad. We cannot expand our consciousness and attain higher states by banishing some elements from consciousness. We have to learn to be big enough to contain contradictions. One difference between Buddhism and traditional Christianity is that nobody is eternally damned in Buddhism. The devil symbolises all that is wicked and bad and is traditionally consigned to everlasting damnation, beyond redemption. It's a long time since I learned my Christian doctrine so the devil may have been rehabilitated by now. In Buddhism this is an impossible notion, for if the devil is not redeemable, then we are not, because all that is wicked is ours, as well as all that is good.
My own experience was that when I began meditating I was not aware of any conflict in me. It all seemed quite simple and straightforward. I wanted to progress spiritually, I wanted to become more aware, more happy, more compassionate and so on and meditation would help me do that, so no conflict. But of course when you meditate you become more aware, you become aware of the nastier aspects of yourself, your selfishness and pettiness and so on. I gradually became aware of aspects of myself that did not want to progress spiritually, did not want to meditate etc, in fact didn't want to be bothered and were screaming, leave me alone. And the conflict got more and more intense, this conflict between my idealism and faith and determination to live a spiritual life and my wanting an easy life that didn't involve any change or difficulty and was completely indulgent. When I'd been meditating for about two years I almost exploded with this conflict as aspects of my psyche that I'd been repressing burst into awareness. I felt very emotionally unstable for several months and went into depression. I hope this doesn't put you off meditation. However, I never lost trust in the practices and theory of Buddhism, I don't really know why. Gradually the conflict in me not only intensified but clarified and during the course of a solitary retreat I came to be able to contain both of these strong tendencies within my view of myself. I was no longer trying to get rid of an aspect of myself. It just seemed to resolve on a deeper level and something else came into being that was larger and softer. I began to have images of lakes in meditation. I became bigger somehow, more expansive. That is what we are aiming at with meditation. We need to become big rather than good. To be big is to contain contradictions. As the American poet, Walt Whitman, said:
“Do I contradict myself?
Very well then ….... I contradict myself
I am large ....... I contain multitudes”
(Song of Myself)
We need to embrace all of us, warts and all, so to speak. We are not good. We are not bad, we are good and bad. That is why we need to transform ourselves and that is why we can transform ourselves. Because if we think we are all good there is no need to change and if we think we are all bad we can't change. But either one of these lopsided states is a state of alienated awareness. And as Bhante Sangharakshita says: “It is better to establish real, living contact with our negative emotions (which means acknowledging them and experiencing them but not indulging them) than to remain in an alienated state and not experience our emotions at all. (A Stream of Stars, p.45)
In the vajra the poisons are recognised and through the power of awareness are transformed into the Wisdoms. Hatred is transformed into the Mirror-like wisdom of Akshobya. Hatred already has in it a sort of sharp objectivity which through the practice of forbearance or patience is transformed into the more benign objectivity and clarity of the Mirror-like Wisdom. Pride is transformed into the Wisdom of Equality, Ratnasambhava's Wisdom. The hallmark of pride is making comparisons with others and through the practice of an attitude of generosity towards everyone, pride or making comparisons is transformed into the ability to relate to others on the basis of their spiritual potential, and the attitude of generosity eventually can become the Wisdom of Equality. Craving or greed is transformed into the discriminating Wisdom of Amitabha. Greed is concerned with preferences, (I like this, I don't like that) and through the practice of deep meditation, the tendency of our mind to make distinctions can be transformed into the an ability to see the unique qualities of individuals and situations, which eventually can become the Discriminating Wisdom. The poison of jealousy or envy is transformed into the All-Accomplishing Wisdom of Amoghasiddhi. Through the practice of fearlessness, courageously taking risks, we can achieve success in whatever we attempt and this brings a confidence that dissolves envy and can eventually become the All-Accomplishing Wisdom. The poison of spiritual ignorance is transformed into the Dharmadhatu or Absolute Wisdom of Vairocana. Through reflection on the essential teachings of the Buddha, seemingly even simple teachings such as 'actions have consequences', our minds become open to the Reality of existence and become gradually saturated with Truth. Spiritual ignorance is slowly dissolved leaving space for the arising of Insight and eventually the attainment of Enlightenment and Absolute Wsidom.
In this way through the practices of patience, generosity, meditation, fearlessness (taking risks) and contemplation the five poisons are transformed into the five Wisdoms and the double vajra is a symbol of the tremendous energy released by this transformation. The single vajra is the emblem of Akshobya and is an indication of energy required for the practice of forbearance (ksanti), the energy required just to be. The double vajra could be seen to symbolise the energy needed in order to be and to do simultaneously. To be centred and calm and at the same time active and effective. The key to this is the practice of awareness or mindfulness which raised to its highest level is the state of Nirvana or Enlightenment.
The centre of the vajra, the sphere, represents the state of complete Enlightenment. The poisons pass through the central sphere on the way to becoming the Wisdoms. What this means is that awareness is the fundamental Buddhist practice which needs to permeate all other practices and a state of bare awareness is a state of freedom. A state of liberation from all the turbulent and unskilful tendencies of the mundane mind. Awareness leads to self-knowledge. We need to know ourselves in order to transform ourselves. Our awareness needs to be permeated by goodwill, which is why we do the Metta Bhavana, as well as the Mindfulness of Breathing.
We need to become aware of our defilements. Aware of the poisons in our minds, aware of our hatred, greed, ignorance, pride and jealousy and we need to maintain an attitude of goodwill towards ourselves at the same time. There is no place for condemnation in Buddhism. No place for condemnation of ourselves or others. There is a place for making judgements and constructive criticisms which are in the context of goodwill or Metta. Bhante Sangharakshita mentions this. He says: “Criticism is not condemnation. I never condemn anyone, since I believe that human beings are capable of change. Criticism if taken in the right spirit helps us to grow.” (A Stream of Stars, p.98) This highlights something else about criticism. It needs to be taken in the right spirit as well as given in the right spirit. The right spirit is a spirit of goodwill. With regard to ourselves we need to be big enough to acknowledge our capacity for evil, for hatred, greed etc., and acknowledge our actual unskilfulness while at the same time maintaining an attitude of goodwill and kindness towards ourselves. With regard to other people and situations, we need to be able to acknowledge the gap between the ideal and the actual while maintaining an attitude of goodwill.
Some people complain about the absence of the ideal, as if other people or circumstances or situation ought to be perfect. But this is not an intelligent way to proceed. We need to work at changing ourselves and the world around us precisely because the actual is not the ideal. Complaining that things are not ideal is like a child complaining that its parents are not perfect. The child doesn't realise that nobody's parents are perfect. (To be fair to children, many adults also complain that their parents were not perfect!). Bhante has something to say about this: “It is sometimes necessary to criticize the weaknesses of others, but people often seem to find it difficult to do so without doing it in a 'hard' sort of way that excludes compassion. Perhaps, in some cases, people criticize others as a way of paying homage to the ideal without actually having to practise that ideal.” (A Stream of Stars, p100)
We need to practise, and by doing that become emotionally big enough to include contradictions and big enough to forgive ourselves and others for failing. If we are big enough to forgive failure in ourselves and others, then there is less fear of failure. The double vajra is a symbol which unites all opposites and encompasses all of Reality. The double vajra is a symbol of the mind of the spiritually aware individual. The individual who is aware and honest and open enough to contain contradictions; aspiration and craving, love and ill-will, faith and doubts. The individual who through awareness and an attitude of goodwill constantly works to transform the poisons of ignorance, greed, hatred, jealousy, pride, and in so doing releases more and more energy for further spiritual practice.
The double vajra could also be seen as a symbol of the Sangha, the spiritual community, the harmony of mutual helpfulness. The Sangha at its best unites all opposites, transcends division and difference and develops co-operation and trust, creating a realm in which we can let go of fear and take risks: risks in communication, risks in self-revelation, risks in generosity, risks in apology and forgiveness. All of this also releases tremendous energy for the good. The double vajra is a symbol of the energy released by the integrating effect of spiritual practice and it is also a reminder to us of the need for constant effort and application if we want to make spiritual progress.
The energy produced by the acknowledgement and transformation of the mental poisons is assured of success because the union of opposites involves encompassing the whole of Reality. In Reality there are no opposites to be united, there are just varying degrees of ignorance obscuring the clarity of how things really are. When we reach closer to an insight into the nature of existence, not obscured by hatred, greed, ignorance, envy or pride, we will have less to fear, because then we will experience less separation from life round us. We and other life are not opposites, we are one, an interconnected whole. As we start to see things from this larger perspective that transcends opposites, there is less and less to fear, until eventually we will understand the message of Amoghasiddhi – there is nothing to fear.
Wednesday, 28 January 1998
Energy In Pursuit Of The Good
This talk was given at the London Buddhist Centre, January 1998
“The striving and onward effort, the exertion and endeavour, the zeal and the ardour, the vigour and fortitude, the state of unfaltering effort, the state of sustained desire, the state of not putting down the yoke and burden, energy, right endeavour, this is viriya.” (Abhidhamma, Dhammasangani, Section 13. Quoted in Sangharakshita, Complete Works, Vol.1, p.439) This is how virya (Pali-viriya) is described in the Pali Canon.
There is a crisper description or definition in the Bodhicaryavatara – virya is, depending on the translator - “The endeavour to do what is skilful”, “Energy in pursuit of the good”, “Finding joy in what is wholesome”, or “Perseverance in the good”, and in the Jewel Ornament of Liberation”, it says that “The essence of strenuousness is to strive for the good and wholesome”. (trans. Guenther, p.182) From these definitions and descriptions we can see that there are two aspects to virya; the aspect of energy or effort and what that energy or effort is directed towards. And for virya to manifest we need both. It is not enough to have energy or enthusiasm; that energy needs to be directed towards what is good or wholesome, our efforts need to be directed towards the skilful.
Perfect Effort is the sixth stage of the Noble Eightfold Path. Perfect Effort consists largely in the practise of the Four Right Efforts. The Four Right Efforts relate to unskilful and skilful mental states. They are the effort to get rid of unskilful mental states, the effort to develop skilful mental sates, the effort to prevent unskilful mental states from arising and the effort to maintain skilful states that are already present. I could speak about virya solely in terms of these four Right Efforts but I have decided to look at virya from another point of view.
Virya appears as one of the five Spiritual Faculties and also as one of the six Paramitas. As one of the five spiritual faculties, virya is balanced by concentration. This is to indicate that virya is not merely a matter of external physical activity, not just a matter of neurotic busyness, but a case of energy based in tranquillity, based upon a healthy integrated personality. As the Buddhist scholar, Dr Conze, puts it “Vigour by itself leads to excitement, and has to be controlled by a development of concentrated calm.” (The Way of Wisdom, Wheel Publication 65/66, p.9) If we are of this sort of excitable restless nature we may need to learn how to sit still and do nothing before we can develop a more true energy in pursuit of the good. Excitability can lose sight of the Good and become a case of activity for its own sake, as ridiculous as a dog chasing it's own tail. So the five Spiritual Faculties highlight the need for balance; balancing Faith with Wisdom and virya with Concentration and underpinning all the virtues with Mindfulness. The Five spiritual Faculties are also sometimes associated with the Mandala of the Five Buddhas. In this connection, virya is associated with Amoghasiddhi, the green Buddha, the Buddha of Action. I will say more about this later. Then we come to virya as one of the Six Perfections.
Perfect Effort in the Noble Eightfold Path is concerned with the transformation of the will, of volition. The Five Spiritual Faculties emphasise the need for virya to be balanced by Concentration, the need for our energy to be based in meditative consciousness, and not just a manifestation of neurotic restlessness. virya as one of the Six Paramitas gives more emphasis to the goal or direction in which the energy is moving. It is “Energy in pursuit of the good” or “the endeavour to do what is skilful”.
This is the energy of the Bodhisattva which flows spontaneously into altruistic, creative, life-enhancing activity. In the Bodhicaryavatara by Shantideva, virya is looked at from the point of view of its opposites and then Shantideva goes into how to develop and maintain virya. So this is what I want to do in this talk. I'm not going to follow Shantideva exactly, but I will draw on some of his categories as a framework for talking about virya. First of all then, what are the opposites of virya, what are the hindrances? Shantideva lists four- namely laziness, clinging to what is vile, despondency and self-contempt. So let's look a bit more closely at these opposites of virya. In the Jewel Ornament of Liberation, sGam Popa, reckons there are three kinds of laziness. They are lassitude. Idleness and gross laziness.
Lassitude is described as “addiction to the pleasures of mental inertia such as sleepiness, restfulness and dreaminess”. (p.182) I don't know if any of you are familiar with this state of sleepiness and dreaminess. Sometimes it can be good, even useful, to allow yourself to relax into a state of dreaminess because your imagination can come into play then and you may experience intuitions or a sense of the connections between disparate things which you couldn't think your way to. However what is being talked about here is “addiction to the pleasures” of sleepiness and dreaminess, which is a state of torpor, of total lack of initiative or urge to act or evolve. It's an animal-like state, this state of mental inertia. Its a waste of the human potential to act , to create, to consciously evolve.
The second kind of laziness is called idleness. The text says, “Idleness is faint-heartedness from thinking how can dejected people like myself ever attain enlightenment even if we try to do so.”. (p.183) So this is a sort of false humility or lack of self-esteem that leads to doing nothing. It's the attitude that says “there is no point in making an effort because I'm such a worthless worm, that I'll never achieve anything or get anywhere”. It's a very debilitating state and it has the ring of self-pity about it, arrogant self-pity. “I'm so special that I'm an exception to the general rule about the ability of humans to unfold their potential”. So this is faint-heartedness.
The third kind of laziness is very interesting; it is called “gross laziness”. The text says, “Gross laziness is addiction to such evil and unwholesome practices as subduing enemies and hoarding money.”. (p.183) This is interesting because it suggests that you can be active, even very active, and still be lazy from a spiritual point of view. “Subduing enemies and hoarding money” could be paraphrased as politics and business. If all your energy is going into the pursuit of power or the accumulation of wealth and possessions, if these things have become ends in themselves for you, then according to the text, you are suffering from gross laziness. This is because you are not facing up to reality. You are hiding from the reality of impermanence. Your life is a form of escapism. This definition of gross laziness as “addiction to such evil and unwholesome practices as subduing enemies and hoarding money” reminds us that virya is not just energy, but energy in pursuit of the good.
That then is laziness, the first of the obstacles or opposites to virya. Then we come to the second which is called “clinging to what is vile.”. This is basically craving and illl-will and it is the opposite to virya because it is such a waste of energy. We experience craving and ill-will because we have a basic wrong view about the the nature of Reality. We experience self and other as essentially separate and this sets up a conflict of interests, which doesn't actually exist. In Reality there is no conflict of interests between self and other, but our limited perspective creates this conflict and this leads to craving and ill-will and the consequent dissipation of energy. Even worse, we are divided against ourselves because we can partially see through the veils of our ignorance and this internal conflict between spiritual aspiration on the one hand and a craving for security on the other, leads to a further loss of energy. This is “clinging to what is vile”. It's very similar to gross laziness, except perhaps it's even more basic. It is the energy that is tied up in keeping the whole edifice of ego intact and defended.
The third opposite of virya is despondency. We mentioned this earlier in relation to idleness and faint-heartedness. Despondency is the tendency to give up because the task seems too much, too daunting. Despondency involves a loss of perspective and following from that a lack of patience. We become despondent when we forget that transformation is a process that happens over time, sometimes almost imperceptibly. We look around us and everything seems today to be just as it was yesterday. These other people around us, who call themselves Buddhists, are just as imperfect as they were a month ago and we ourselves are still making the same mistakes we made before and it's all so frustrating and nothing seems to be changing and why don't they change and why can't we change and we get despondent and fed up and feel that it's no use trying because you try and try and nothing seems to change. And so we've lost perspective and got into a state of frustrated impatience, which prevents us from making the necessary effort to grow and prevents us from seeing the growth that is happening all around us. We become like someone who can only see the signs of winter even though the signs of spring are everywhere. We observe the world through the grey glass of our despondency and lose our will to strive. This is very energy draining. We are on the verge of giving up the pursuit of the good because we have become blind to the good.
The fourth obstacle to virya is self-contempt. This is slightly different from despondency although closely connected to it. Despondency is faintheartedness in the face of the huge task of self-transformation and pursuit of the good. Self-contempt is more narcissistic than that. It centres on our unique inability to change or grow. Our eyes are turned upon ourselves in a fascinated, all-absorbing, criticism. We seem to be worthless, incapable, unworthy of consideration by others and yet by some strange quirk, we are also the centre of the universe, unfairly treated, victimised, bullied and generally to be pitied. Self-hatred is a complex and common thing. It sometimes leads us to undermining ourselves and feeling unable to act and it sometimes gets projected out and is experienced as an uncaring, cruel and callous world around us that is totally unfair. However it is experienced, it is an obstacle to virya because it doesn't look up, to see the good and because it keeps ones energy in a whirlpool of absorbing self-centredness.
These are the four opposites of virya according to Shantideva: laziness, clinging to what is vile, despondency and self-contempt. Shantideva's response to these is characteristic and may seem very unsympathetic. But, perhaps if Shantideva seems unsympathetic in his response, it is because we haven't understood the great difference between pity and compassion. Shantideva says many things to wake us up to what is really going on . For instance, he shouts: “Hey you, expecting results without effort! So sensitive! So long-suffering! You, in the clutches of death, acting like an immortal! Hey, sufferer, you are destroying yourself! Now that you have met with the boat of human life, cross over the mighty river of suffering. Fool, there is no time to sleep! It is hard to catch this boat again. One should endeavour to increase ones exertion through the powers of desire, pride, delight, renunciation, dedication and self-mastery.” (Bodhicaryavatara , trans. Crosby/Skilton, p. 68-70) I'm going to to use this list of six “powers”, as Shantideva calls them, as a framework for the rest of this talk.
The first thing we need then in order to develop virya, according to Shantideva, is desire. The Sanskrit word that is translated as desire is “chanda” and the desire that Shantideva is talking about is Dharma-chanda. Dharmachanda is desire for the good, desire for for the skilful. We are being reminded again that virya is not just energy, it is energy in pursuit of the good. In order to pursue the good we need to know the good and also feel an emotional engagement with the good. The good is what is spiritually beneficial, it is what conduces to the evolving of higher states of consciousness. Whatever is beneficial to us in this way is also beneficial to others. Whatever is in our interests spiritually speaking, must also be in the interests of others. The power of desire is the power of our aspiration for self-transformation, it's the power of our faith in the Dharma and its methods, it's the power of our passion for the good, for the benefit of humanity. This desire, this passion, this faith moves us to act to make changes in our lives and to help others.
The second power that Shantideva mentions is the power of pride. This might seem quite strange at first. We are used to thinking of pride as something negative, like arrogance or conceit. But what Shantideva is talking about is the opposite to self-contempt. It is pride in our ability to change, to transform ourselves. It is pride in the fact that we are aware enough to want to attain higher states of consciousness. We can be proud of the fact that we want to evolve and that we have the ability to evolve. This is something that we perhaps don't appreciate enough. Our tendency may be to concentrate on our difficulties and what hinders us from growing, but we can, and indeed should, also give attention to what is in our favour. We should value our aspiration, value our understanding, value our pursuit of wisdom and compassion, value our efforts to change, value the progress we are making. By valuing ourselves in this way, by appreciating ourselves, we cultivate a positive pride and dignity. We refuse to be incapacitated by undermining thoughts and feelings. We take initiative, we act, we make an effort, because we know we can and we know that our dignity as human beings demands that we make an effort to consciously evolve. A positive pride can help to activate our energy in pursuit of the good. This is the Buddha-pride that Shantideva alludes to: “Today my birth is fruitful. My human life is justified. Today I am born into the family of the Buddha. Now I am the Buddha's son. So that there be no blemish upon this spotless family, I must now act as becomes my family. As a blind man might find a jewel in heaps of rubbish, so too this Awakening Mind has somehow appeared in me” (Bodhicaryavatara , trans. Crosby/Skilton, p.22)
The third power that helps us to make greater effort is what Shantideva calls “delight”. Delight here is the very opposite of despondency. Delight is an intense pleasure and satisfaction derived from performing skilful actions. Shantideva asserts that there is great joy and delight to be had from performing a task if we put ourselves wholeheartedly into it and if it is benign activity, helpful to others and related to out spiritual aspirations. He says: “One should be addicted solely to the task that one is undertaking, one should be intoxicated by that task, insatiable, like someone hankering for the pleasure and the fruit of love-play. ..how can one, for whom the task itself is satisfaction, be satisfied without a task? How can one get enough of the benign, ambrosial acts of merit, sweet in their results?” (ibid p.72/73)
Shantideva uses the language of addiction, intoxication, insatiability, hankering: language that is usually associated with sense pleasure such as sex, drugs, alcohol, gambling and he says this is how we can feel or even should feel about the “benign ambrosial acts of merit”. This is how a Bodhisattva feels, thoroughly delighted by skilful activity. The Bodhisattva is said to play, like a child playing games. Bodhisattvas play at performing heroic and compassionate deeds. A Bodhisattva goes from task to task joyfully, plunging from one task to another, like an elephant plunging into a cool pond of water on a hot day.
We can generate energy by cultivating a delight in skilful activity. If we delight in acts of generosity and in efforts to go beyond our limitations, then we will continue to be generous and to take the risks necessary to go beyond ourselves. To delight in our work, we need to make the connection between what we are doing and our spiritual aspirations. Our activity needs to be saturated with a vision of the spiritual Ideal. If we can see the spiritual ideal in our activity, then we can see the beautiful and the good in our activity and seeing the beautiful and the good brings satisfaction and delight. This is quite a difficult area for many people. It is all too easy to become very concerned with difficulties at work or difficulties in communication and to lose sight of the spiritual benefits and the spiritual necessity of working with and transcending those difficulties. We need something to remind us of the bigger picture, the larger perspective. We need to find ways to bring us back to an awareness of our ideals and how our ideals can permeate our whole life. If we manage to maintain an awareness of our spiritual ideals and values then we will have the energy to deal with difficulties and the energy to be creative and take initiative in our lives. We will progress spiritually and experience the joys of the spiritual life. Joy leading to greater joy.
The fourth power which enables us to increase our exertions is renunciation, according to Shantideva. Renunciation has a very specific meaning here. It means stopping an activity which cannot be effective. It is appropriate to make an effort and invest energy if we can be effective, but when our activity ceases to be effective then it is time to stop. Effective in the spiritual sense of course means conducive to the development and maintenance of higher states of consciousness and conducive to the welfare of ourselves and others. This points to the need for balanced effort and also points to the fact that our activities should include something of our spiritual goal in them. As Gandhi said, the means must include the end.
There is no point in carrying on an activity which is no longer effective. For instance, there would be no point in me carrying on talking if everyone else got up and left or if you all started talking amongst yourselves. It would be a wasted effort on my part. We need to know when to relax our efforts or switch to a different task. To know that, we need to know what it means to be effective and to know what it means to be effective requires us to keep our goal in sight. Renunciation also has the sense of gradually letting go of activities that are opposed to the spiritual life. Our energy can be too crude or coarse and by gradually letting go of our more crude pursuits and gradually engaging in more refined activities we can refine our energy, so that there will be less of a gap between our ordinary life and meditative states. We usually see this as involving some sort of engagement with the arts both as practitioner and consumer.
We can see renunciation in terms of gradually refining our energy and we can see renunciation in terms of balanced effort. There is also renunciation as letting go; letting go of attachment to material possessions, letting go of fixed views and opinions, letting go of attachment to certainty and security, letting go of attachment to comfort and pleasure, letting go, eventually, of a fixed sense of who we are and being content to be an impermanent process that is permanently in process of change. Being attached to a sense of the fixedness of things and the fixedness of ourself, leads only to suffering and pain. As Shantideva puts it: “All those who suffer on the world do so because f their desire for their own happiness. All those happy in the world are so because of their desire for the happiness of others.” (ibid, p.99) George Eliot brings out the same theme in her novel “Romola”. Here the heroine Romola is speaking: “There was a man to whom I was very near, so that I could see a great deal of his life, who made almost every one fond of him, for he was young, and clever, and beautiful, and his manners to all were gentle and kind. I believe, when I first knew him, he never thought of doing anything cruel or base. But because he tried to slip away from everything that was unpleasant, and cared for nothing else so much as his own safety, he came at last to commit some of the basest deeds -such as make men infamous. He denied his father, and left him to misery; he betrayed every trust that was reposed in him, that he might keep himself safe and get rich and prosperous. Yet calamity overtook him.” By learning to make a balanced effort, to refine our energies and to gradually renounce attachments and any fixed sense of ourself, we can become more spontaneously energetic in pursuit of the good.
The next way to cultivate virya, according to Shantideva, is by “dedication”. Dedication in this context is about the practice of mindfulness and in particular mindfulness of the mind. This of course brings us back to the four right efforts which we mentioned earlier. These are the effort to get rid of unskilful thoughts that have already arisen, the effort to prevent the arising of unskilful thoughts which have not yet arisen, the effort to develop skilful thoughts and the effort to maintain skilful thoughts already present: eradication, prevention, developing and maintaining. This practice involves what is known as guarding the gates of the senses. We receive input though our senses and respond to that input with feelings, thoughts and emotions. We need to maintain awareness of what we are allowing in, what input we expose ourselves to and we need also to keep a close watch on how we respond to what we receive through our senses. This amounts to a willingness to take responsibility for our emotional and mental states. It is a willingness to change, to move away from being the victim of circumstance and the victim of moods to taking initiative and making efforts to be more in charge of our lives and ourselves. This requires perseverance, stamina and a belief in the value of skilfulness. We need to be dedicated to a constant, ongoing cumulative practice of mindfulness and dedicated to attaining the fruits of spiritual practice.
Here are some exhortations from Shantideva to inspire us to a more thorough and immediate practice of mindfulness. “As poison, finding the blood, spreads throughout the body, so, finding a weak point, a fault will spread throughout the mind.” “So, on the approach of drowsiness or lethargy one should immediately counteract it, as one would jump up immediately were a snake to slide into one's lap.” “At every single lapse one should burn befittingly with remorse, then reflect, “How might I act so that this might not happen to me again?” “One should look forward to society or a given task with this motive: “How may I practice the discipline of mindfulness in these circumstances?” Remembering the teaching on vigilance, one should make oneself versatile, as one always prepares oneself prior to undertaking a task. In the very same way that cotton is swayed to the direction of the wind as it comes and goes, one should be directed by one's endeavour, and in this way one's spiritual power grows strong.” (ibid, p.73/74) Dedication to mindfulness keeps our mind on the task and concentrates our energy for a more potent practice of generosity, ethics, meditation and wisdom.
The sixth and final way to cultivate virya mentioned by Shantideva is self-mastery. Shantideva doesn't say much about this. Self-mastery is concerned with discipline. It is a matter of integrating our energies around our spiritual aspiration so that we are sufficiently motivated to act consistently and persistently in ways that will further our spiritual progress and be of benefit to ourselves and others. Without the motivation it is not possible to be a disciplined practitioner of the Dharma. It just becomes a cold struggle. If we are motivated and our emotional energies are flowing towards our ideals then there is satisfaction and fulfilment in the discipline of practice. We have the satisfaction of knowing that our ethical actions and our efforts in meditation are of great benefit and we gradually begin to experience the satisfaction of the results of our practice. Self-mastery involves a gradual gathering of our energies and focussing ourselves on the self-transcending goal of our practice. The more we focus on our practice, the more our ability to focus grows. The more disciplined we are in our practice of meditation, ethics and study, the more capable we become of maintaining a satisfying discipline.
We've looked at the six powers which Shantideva says we need to practise in order to cultivate and maintain virya; the active aspect of the spiritual life. Virya as one of the five spiritual faculties is sometimes associated with the Buddha Amoghasiddhi. As you know, Amoghasiddhi is one of the five Jinas, one of the Buddhas in the Mandala of the five Buddhas. He is the Buddha of the Northern Realm. He is green in colour. He is seated on a lotus throne which is supported by mythical creatures, half human half bird and his right hand is held aloft, palm facing outwards, in a gesture that indicates fearlessness. His left hand rests in his lap holding a double vajra; a symbolic double thunderbolt. Amoghasiddhi is known as the Buddha of Action and his Wisdom is the All-Accomplishing Wisdom. It is very appropriate that Amoghasiddhi should be associated with virya because to exercise our energy in pursuit of the good we need to overcome our fear. We need to be willing to take risks. There are dangers involved in living the spiritual life. We can experience hurt and upset and humiliation as we strive to overcome our limitations. And we need to be willing to go through the transforming fires of discomfort, hurt, upset and humiliation if we really want to grow. To grow is to take risks, to step into the unknown.
We sometimes speak of this as entering the crucial situation or even entering the cremation ground. The cremation ground represents the place where we encounter our fears. To enter the cremation ground means to deliberately face our fears and thus transform them. When our fear is transformed what appears is the Dakini, a naked female figure who dances with abandonment through the sky. The Dakini , the sky dancer, is the energy liberated from fear, it's the freedom and joy that awaits us at the other side of our fear. (Just as an aside here, I think dancing and indeed the physical disciplines such as yoga, TaiChi, and martial arts are very useful in the freeing of energy and emotion which may be locked in our stiff bodies).
We are afraid of so many things. We are afraid of what other people will think about us, or what they might think about us or what they might say about us and what they might say to us. We are afraid of failing. We are afraid of succeeding. We are afraid of anger, our own anger and other peoples anger. We are afraid of being bad and we are afraid to be too good. We are afraid of being swamped by the group and we are afraid of standing out from the crowd. We are afraid of being led and afraid of taking the lead. We are afraid of being isolated and lonely and afraid of initiating communication. We are sometimes afraid of the unknown, of what might happen to us, of what might be demanded of us.
And in spite of all that fear, fear of change, we do embark on the spiritual path and we do change. We do take risks. Meditation is a risky business, because we discover new things about ourselves, some of them not entirely to our advantage. Honest communication can be risky for the same reason. Dharma study can be risky because our whole world view can be threatened or even destroyed, by contact with new ideas and bigger perspectives. Getting involved with a Buddhist spiritual community can be risky because we quickly lose our romantic views about the holy purity of Buddhists. Trying to live by high ideals is risky because we are quite likely to fail frequently. Being alive is risky because we are unlikely to escape death. But we take risks and if we want to have any sort of satisfactory or fulfilling life we have to take risks.
We fulfil our potential by expanding emotionally and mentally and by being expansive in our communication. We have to go beyond the safe and comfortable limits that habit has accustomed us to and take the risk of being more emotionally visible and available, the risk of having our views and opinions challenged to the core and the risk of being rejected by other people. By taking risks, by going beyond our comfortable boundaries, we enter upon the adventure of the spiritual path, the adventure of expanding awareness and deeper communication. And this is the only way to live really, as far as I'm concerned. Life is a risk worth taking. The alternative is to tread water until we “kick the bucket”!
Amoghasiddhi holds up his right hand, palm outwards, in a gesture that symbolises confidence. The hand is open and outgoing. We can contemplate the significance of Amoghasiddhi's gesture and allow ourselves to be influenced to become more open, outgoing and confident. Each one of us has a unique and valuable contribution to make in the world and with a little more confidence, and pride in ourselves, we can give full rein to our abilities and potential. We need to work on ourselves, in meditation and communication, to gain greater self-knowledge and free up the energy being wasted in internal conflict and fear. When we can acknowledge our aspirations and our unskilfulness, our love and our hatred, our generosity and our selfishness, when we have a big enough perspective on ourselves to embrace our contradictions, then we are moving towards the tremendous power symbolised by the double vajra. The double vajra is a symbol of the union of all opposites and a symbol of the energy inherent in that electric embrace; the energy which can transform all obstacles, surmount all difficulties. This is the energy of Amoghasiddhi which leads to the All-Accomplishing Wisdom. The All-Accomplishing wisdom is the spontaneous, natural flood of helpfulness that pours forth from an Enlightened being. It is constantly creative, fearless and unstoppable.
When we have faith and confidence in the Spiritual Ideal, the Buddha, and in the Spiritual Path, the Dharma, and when we wholeheartedly take the risk, the step into the unknown, of living out the spiritual life with our friends in the Sangha, then we will gradually loosen up and unleash the energy and abandonment that will make our lives fulfilling to ourselves and an inspiration and boon to others.